cameronm on the other hand thought "Yay! I can squee about Dr Who and the awesomeness of Stephen Moffat with other fans!"
Afterwards he asked me with a haunted expression "But...how? How can they think all of RTD's episodes were good and all of Moffat's bad? HOW CAN THEY HATE AMY? IT MAKES NO SENSE" and I told him that this is why I am not in Dr Who fandom, apart from reading the journals of people like you and talking to the commenters on my Amy/River fic (who are by their nature less prone to Amy/River/etc hate)
EDIT: Also the Doctor having any kind of emotional involvement with another character would cheapen his love for Rose ahahaha.
no subject
Afterwards he asked me with a haunted expression "But...how? How can they think all of RTD's episodes were good and all of Moffat's bad? HOW CAN THEY HATE AMY? IT MAKES NO SENSE" and I told him that this is why I am not in Dr Who fandom, apart from reading the journals of people like you and talking to the commenters on my Amy/River fic (who are by their nature less prone to Amy/River/etc hate)
EDIT: Also the Doctor having any kind of emotional involvement with another character would cheapen his love for Rose ahahaha.