lizbee: A sketch of myself (Default)
1. Your main fandom of the year?

Still Star Trek, my friends. It doesn't deserve my love, but it has it.

2. Your favorite film watched this year?

Dune Part Two. I really appreciated how it delved deep into the stuff that Lynch's film had to skip: Paul's rise as a terrorist freedom fighter, the Bene Gesserit's plans, Jessica's manipulations. It wasn't a perfect film, but I thoroughly enjoyed it.

3. Your favorite book read this year?

I'll get to my annual book post in a few days, but roughly by category:

Contemporary mystery: Listen for the Lie by Amy Tintera. The murder of the heroine's best friend is the subject of a true crime podcast, and after all these years, she is still the number one suspect in the eyes of the world.

YA: The Fire Keeper's Daughter by Angeline Boulley. A thriller set in the Indigenous community of Michigan.

Non-Fiction: Flying Blind: The 737-Max Tragedy and the Fall of Boeing by Peter Robison, Challenger: A true story of heroism and disaster on the edge of space by Adam Higginbotham, and Character Limit: How Elon Musk destroyed Twitter by Kate Conger and Ryan Mac. These books have a lot in common, starting with "actually, this is sort of Ronald Reagan's fault".

4. Your favorite album or song to listen to this year?

The Great Impersonator by Halsey. I was only peripherally aware of Halsey as a performer, but I heard she had an album coming out where she paid tribute to a lot of iconic acts, including PJ Harvey, Tori Amos and Bjork. As someone who was a teenager in the '90s, I was intrigued. I expected a cover album, but instead it's a series of pastiches as Halsey draws on her inspirations as she writes about being treated for leukemia and the possibility of dying young.

Not every homage is effective, but it's overall a really strong album, and it really spoke to me as I dealt with my own health issues.

5. Your favorite TV show of the year?

Star Trek: Prodigy, my beloved. After season 1, I was going around saying it's the objectively best Star Trek since DS9; after season 2, other people were saying it as well. And they were correct. I know it's heavily pushed in fandom as "Star Trek: Janeway" or a sequel to Voyager, and it is that, but I think that does a disservice to a series which very much stands on its own, and understands that obscure references and fan service are meaningless unless you're also telling a good story that's about the new characters.

6. Your favorite online community of the year?


I'm in a Discord community that started as a space for fans of Admiral Cornwell, and now we just mostly hang out and chill.

7. Your best new fandom discovery of the year?

I belatedly learned there's a new TV adaptation of PD James's Adam Dalgliesh mysteries, with three seasons of six episodes each, and I love the choices it makes. The books spanned the 1960s to the early 2000s, but Dalgliesh concentrates the stories in the 1970s, with the crumbling of the social contract and Thatcher slouching towards Downing Street.

I think it's fair -- if not overly generous -- to say that James was a reactionary and rather conservative author, and the TV series makes a lot of choices she would have utterly hated: lots of characters of colour, overt queerness where she used subtext (and a strong air of distaste), emphasis on Dalgliesh as a man who is accepted by establishment figures because he is white and educated, but who holds himself at a distance.

The best choice it makes is casting a mixed race actress as Kate Miskin. Kate is introduced in the later books as a working class cop with a chip on her shoulder about her education, because she feels her schools spent too much time teaching that racism is bad, rather than actually educating her. Obviously this is James's bugbear. When I last reread the books, in the mid-2000s, I was like, "Either Kate is incredibly racist, or she is Black and didn't need to be told that racism is bad." And so I headcanoned her as Black. Clearly the people behind the TV series felt the same way, and the writing is nuanced enough that this doesn't feel like simple colourblind casting with no eye to subtext.

The downside is that now I ship Kate/Dalgliesh, even though the series has made it clear it's not going there in any meaningful way. Such is life.

Bonus entry: Dune: Prophecy. I do not know if it is actually good -- the first act of the first episode is actively bad -- but it spoke to me on a profound level even before a stout, middle-aged woman was Touched By Destiny.

8. Your biggest fandom disappointment of the year?

The fifth and final season of Star Trek: Lower Decks. I very quickly went from "it's a shame Lower Decks was cancelled, but five seasons is a good run" to "Lower Decks should have been cancelled sooner, actually." Season five felt formless and half-baked. Mariner barely had an arc; Tendi was out of character; Rutherford was hardly in it at all. Only Boimler got coherent and consistent character development, and it was predictable at every turn. It was giving burnout in a really sad way. Fortunately the coda to the final episode was so delightful that it almost made up for everything which had gone before, so Lower Decks didn't go out on a wholly sour note for me.

9. Your fandom boyfriend of the year?
A middle-aged white man with white-blond hair and a neat goatee and large, pointed ears.

If you are in fandom long enough, a Callum Keith Rennie character will be assigned to you.

I know some people were miffed that Discovery introduced a new white man in its final season, gave him a lot of screen time and fans went gaga for it. And I totally get that. I am not proud of who I became when Rayner turned up.

But Discovery needed him. I know I always rail against fans who can't tell the difference between a found family and a cult, but the Discovery crew are absolutely a cult, and the show really benefited from having a guy walk in and go, "Oh no, all this emotional honesty and openness and mutual respect is freaking me out. Please don't make me open up to you. I will completely support you, but I will be a grumpy bastard while I do it."

And he's a fantastic foil for Michael, given that he's where she was in season 1: demoted, roiling with trauma and anger and desperation to please. I don't precisely ship Michael/Rayner, but I absolutely believe he is in love with her. I feel like if we had gotten a sixth season, we would have gotten a lot more stuff about the Breen, Rayner's trauma, and probably more Primarch Tahal. (Speaking of people I definitely don't ship Rayner with, but actually I do.)

Bonus boyfriend: Chakotay, but only in the Prodigy episodes where he's bearded and has his forearms out.
A CGI figure of a Native American man with greying hair and a full beard, wearing a tattered T-shirt, holding a metal rod like a weapon.

Look, the animators knew what they were doing. Does he look like Robert Beltran? Uh, no. Do I care? Also no.

I have to give Prodigy props overall for taking Voyager's worst character and making him complex and compelling, but they really missed a trick when they let him shave and put a proper shirt on.

Honorary mentions: Lucanis, Daniel Dae Kim as Fire Lord Ozai.

10. Your fandom girlfriend of the year?

Give it up for Valya and Tula Harkonnen!
Two middle-aged white women with dark hair wearing black robes. One is stout and wears a heavy silver necklace; the other is slimmer and wears no jewellery.

Yes, they're running a eugenics cult, they've killed a lot of people, they have lied and manipulated and don't intend to stop until they've engineered themselves a Timothée Chalamet. But have you considered: I love them.

11. Your biggest squee moment of the year?

Rayner takes the chair. Michael Burnham gets her happy ending. The announcement that Tilly will be a recurring character in Starfleet Academy. Wesley Crusher in Prodigy.

12. The most missed of your old fandoms?

Sometimes I look in on Doctor Who and miss feeling excited about it. I assume that day will come again, but these things are cyclical.

13. The fandom you haven't tried yet, but want to?

I bought Fallout 4 for Xbox two years ago, and I still haven't cracked it open!

14. Your biggest fan anticipations for the New Year?
A poster for Star Trek: Section 31: Michelle Yeoh dressed in black leather strides towards the camera. The dominant colours are neon yellow and hot pink.

This is going to be my entire personality for the foreseeable future and I will not apologise.
lizbee: A sketch of myself (Default)
Usually I have opinions about Star Trek and fandom for free, but when my friend Alex invited me to contribute to her new journal and offered to pay me, I said yes, and proceeded to go on a very long rant about bigotry among Trekkies. Then I went back and cut some of the more vibes-based tangents, double checked all my sources, and here we are: 

The Diversity Paradox - Star Trek, Star Trek fandom, and the limits of fandom as progressivism

If I may toot my own horn a little louder, I'm particularly proud of this section: 

You might say, “Don’t read the comments.” And that’s fair—but fandom is the comments section.

We’re all here because we looked at a creative work and went, “I love that/I hate that/I have complex feelings I need to explore/I need to know what happens next and I want to discuss all the possibilities/I need to find out minute details about every single starship that appeared on screen/I will actually die if these fictional characters don’t kiss/a combination of some or all of these feelings.” Fandom is more than the act of consumption. Fandom is in the creation that follows, whether that’s through a fan fiction or art, or reviews, or essays, or the conversations between strangers that take place online.

In “Balance of Terror”, Kirk tells a prejudiced crewman to keep his bigotry in his quarters. It’s a snappy line that fits neatly into a single animated gif, so it’s frequently rolled out by fans as a “solution” to the problem of bigotry in fandom. But very few people identify as a bigot, especially in Star Trek fandom. Karen Q. Fangirl isn’t going, “I have a terrible problem with misogynoir, I really hate Black women,” she’s saying, “Look, I just think Michael Burnham and Raffi Musiker and Beckett Mariner don’t belong in Starfleet.” Just as her mother, thirty years ago, complained that Benjamin Sisko was there to serve political correctness, and anyway, isn’t he just too angry to be a good leader? And just as her grandmother wrote Kirk/Spock stories in which Uhura simply did not appear.

“Don’t read the comments/don’t engage with the bigots/keep your bigotry in your quarters” just cedes the room to the noisiest and worst people in fandom. As a solution to the problem, it’s as intellectually and morally lazy as the multiple episodes of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds which posit that the torture of children of colour is a necessary sacrifice to maintain a thriving utopia.
 

lizbee: (Star Trek: Georgiou (Section 31 apple))
I keep seeing people declaring that "no one" wants this series. Which is a lie, because I want it very much and deeply resent the pandemic for delaying filming.

(I realise this is the very least of the problems with the pandemic, but it's one of them.)

Anyway, literally all we know about the series is that Michelle Yeoh is led, Erika Lippolt and Bo-Yeon Kim are showrunners, and Alex Kurtzman said in an interview that it's about women, and particularly young women.

We especially don't know when in canon it will be set, but I have some ideas...

Poll #24945 An extremely serious poll about Star Trek: Section 31
Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 36


Star Trek: Section 31 will be set...

View Answers

In the 32nd century. David Cronenberg will make regular appearances. The big bad is played by David Lynch.
8 (22.2%)

Concurrent with Strange New Worlds. Every single episode ties in with TOS and ends with Michelle Yeoh saying, "This one's for you, fanboys!" straight to camera.
3 (8.3%)

Concurrent with Star Trek: Picard. It's a blatant exercise in putting Yeoh and Stewart in a room together, but no one minds because hi, have you seen those two act?
13 (36.1%)

Hopping across the multiverse. Zachary Quinto is a Very Special Guest Star. Jason Isaacs can appear sometimes if he wants, but never as prime!Lorca and he's not allowed to wear a shirt.
11 (30.6%)

Something equally hilarious which I shall expound upon in the comments.
1 (2.8%)

lizbee: (Star Trek: Tilly and Michael)
Star Trek tie-in novels have a gender problem.

Decade by decade, series by series, there has been a steady decline in the number of women writing Trek tie-ins. The percentage has dropped from a remarkable 60% in the 1980s to just 12% in the 2010s.

Read my deep dive into gender parity (or ... not) in Star Trek tie-in fiction at my blog. Complete with infographics, gratuitous Joanna Russ quotes, a digression into Star Wars tie-in novels, and the question: where did all the women go? And what can we, as fans, do about it?
lizbee: (Star Trek: Kat (bridge - commanding))
This is an impossible question. It's like asking me to choose my favourite friend.

TNG was my first Trek. It's comfortable and familiar, and yet sometimes still surprises me.

Voyager took me from adolescence to adulthood, and formed a lot of my tastes and preferences.

Discovery gave me inspiration when my well was dry, and I fell in love with a degree of enthusiasm I really didn't think I was capable of anymore. I'd be less disappointed by season 2 if I didn't love the series and characters -- yes, even the ones who aren't Kat -- so much.

TOS is fun and funny and occasionally brilliant. DS9 is more than occasionally brilliant, and clever, and important. (I suppose, if we were going with the friendship analogy, DS9 is the acquaintance I admire very much, but am too intimidated by to seek a closer relationship.) ENT sets out the groundwork and worldbuilding for the series that came before and after. TAS is ... there.

I have no doubt I'll love Picard, and find joy in Lower Decks, and there's about a 95% chance that I will take the first older women in a position of authority to appear in the untitled Nickelodeon animated YA series and attach myself to her like a limpet clinging to a rock.

One of the things I realised, coming back to Star Trek fandom in 2017, is that it's okay to walk away for a decade. The franchise, and the fandom, will still go on, and if you choose to return, that's not a step backwards, it's just a reunion with an old friend.
lizbee: (Star Trek: Janeway)
Every now and then, this stupid franchise I love throws out something meaningful. Something significant. Something worth remembering.

But what's going through my head at any given moment is this:



Unless it's 8:25 on a weekday morning, in which case it's this:



"That nebula" in this case being the espresso machine at work.


Day 30 - Favourite Trek Series
lizbee: (Star Trek: Georgiou (closer))
When I started writing Trek fic again in 2017, I made a conscious decision to name starships after women of STEM, space exploration and science fiction. And while I'm on hiatus from fic writing on account of trying really, really hard to get my novel drafted, I still haven't gotten around to creating a USS Northcutt -- named for Poppy Northcutt, the only woman in mission control for many of the Apollo missions.

(She is still alive, now working as a feminist advocate, and she's still pretty salty about being left out of Apollo 13, if you were wondering.)

Two days left!

Day 29 - Favorite Trek Quote
Day 30 - Favorite Trek Series
lizbee: (Star Trek: SMG (Vulcan salute))
My first instinct was to say that I wouldn't date any of these giant disaster people. Messes, all of them. Yes, even Picard.

But then I remembered ... Tuvok.

Respectful. Funny. Won't burden you with his emotions. Has great pyjamas. Plays the lute. Sings. Breeds orchids. And he spends the better part of a decade on the other side of the galaxy, which is exactly what I would want in a spouse.

T'Pel's a lucky woman.

The remaining days don't even need a cut tag anymore:

Day 28 - Name Your Own Starship
Day 29 - Favorite Trek Quote
Day 30 - Favorite Trek Series
lizbee: (Star Trek: SMG (Vulcan salute))
I don't have any firm answers for this, save Not Earth, because Trek always makes Earth look so hideously sterile. (My headcanon is that, between the loss of life in world war three and the development of warp drive and interstellar colonialism a few generations later, Earth is relatively underpopulated by the 23rd and 24th centuries. But that's no excuse for how bland it appears!)

(Yes, I realise this is a result of limited budget, time, etc. Still.)

Anyway, I'm nicking [personal profile] selenak's answer: Bajor. After it has rebuilt following the Occupation, of course. A variety of ecosystems means they probably have some nice beaches somewhere; there'll be museums and historical sites to visit; your chances of being blown up by isolationists or possessed by ancient evil are only marginally higher than on Vulcan. And, as she says, Bajoran food always looks good.

(Quark says they make terrible beer, but luckily I don't drink beer, and also I don't trust the palate of a man who eats tube grubs.)

Four days left! )
lizbee: (Star Trek: Kat (bridge - commanding))
Though "Lethe" was the episode where Kat Cornwell walked into my head (where she remains, despite all attempts to evict her), my actual favourite Disco episode is "The War Without, The War Within".

It's the closest thing we get to a Katcentric episode (the perils of attaching oneself to a mere recurring character), and also a pretty chilling look at the Federation on the brink of collapse: Kat is vapourising fortune cookies; Sarek's so stressed out he's becoming an empathetic and supportive parent.

It also gives us the "I don't have to tell you it's the middle of the night" scene, for everyone who wants to ship Michael with an older female authority figure but found her relationship with Georgiou too overtly maternal. AND Kat meets Emperor Georgiou. Or, for the hetshippers, there's her claim that prime!Lorca was "reasoned" and "measured"; to which I say, FOOTAGE NOT FOUND.

Some stuff also happens that involves other characters, and it's all great (okay, I take issue with Tilly's attitude towards Michael and Ash, but it makes sense for her character), AND L'Rell has her second big scene with Kat -- OH NO I'm talking about Kat again. This is what it's like living in my head, it's very dull.

Five days left! )
lizbee: A sketch of myself (Default)
"Favourite Starship", "Best Overall Space Vessel", whoever came up with this meme was determined that no one would be able to give a smartass answer to "favourite ship".

I was going to make a crack about how this is basically the same question as the earlier starship one, but then I realised I had a different answer.

The best overall space vessel is ... the USS Defiant.

Mostly for external reasons: its overall aesthetic is similar to Voyager -- grey and silver, v stylish -- but it doesn't have any of the comforts we're used to seeing on a 24th century starship. No seat for the first officer, tiny shared quarters with bunks, a cramped little mess hall. It looks like what it's meant to be: a tough little warship.

Which makes it particularly galling that it's disabled within a few minutes of its fight with the Borg. IT WAS DESIGNED TO FIGHT THE BORG. COMMANDER SHELBY KNOWS HER SHIT, DAMMIT.

(Is it book canon or my own headcanon that Shelby was behind the design of the Defiant? I know Sisko also worked on it, but he doesn't join the project until after Wolf 356, whereas she was designing anti-Borg weapons a year in advance. Either way.)

The final five days. )
lizbee: A sketch of myself (Default)
Obviously it's the replicator, our ticket to fully automated luxury gay space communism.

As long as we're doing prequels, one of the stories I want to see is the evolution from whatever vaguely capitalist system existed between First Contact to what we have by Discovery's era. Because surely the entire human diaspora didn't embrace the new technology right away? I feel like this is a potentially interesting story, although maybe only to me.

The great mystery of replicators: why, in a world where you can make any article of clothing you dream of, everyone's wearing jumpsuits instead of dressing like Lady Gaga every day. Only Lwaxana Troi and Amanda Grayson have embraced the full potential of the technology.

The remaining days. )
lizbee: (Star Trek: Saavik)
Yesterday was A DAY. I got to work forty minutes early, thinking to have a nice, leisurely cup of coffee, update my blogs and read the internet before I had to begin. Instead, it was all hands on deck, and I worked through my lunch break as well.

ANYWAY.

Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country was the first Trek film I saw, and it's still my favourite. It's probably the source of my love for awkward dinner parties as a trope; I adore the show trial and nearly everything else in it, with the exception of the Spock-Valeris forced mind meld. Or, rather, the choice to make it a sexy forced mind meld. Oh, and the bit where Uhura can't speak Klingon, because what? But everything else: wonderful.

It's aged really well as a story -- not so much as a piece of film, I definitely don't recommend watching the Blu-Ray on a HD
TV, the results will not be pretty -- and pays off a lot of things from the earlier films, from Kirk's anger after the death of his son to the presence of Starfleet officers we know in the conspiracy.

If CBS/its licensees ever want to do a tie-in comic or novel about Valeris's rehabilitation, [personal profile] pixiedane and I are ready and willing to write it.

ALSO, Azetbur calls out racism in Federation language ("Human rights. The very term is racist.") because she is magnificent. Ask me about my headcanon that L'Rell mentored Li'l Azetbur.

(I used to think it was ridiculous that the Klingon Empire could have female chancellors in the 23rd century, but not allow women to serve on the High Council in the 24th. Now, in 2019, I get it.)

The final week. )
lizbee: (Star Trek: Seven (Picard))
The first time I saw [personal profile] nostalgia refer to Odo as a fascist, I was like, "Hang on, that's a bit unfair."

Then I watched DS9 again, and frankly, with each successive rewatch, it becomes increasingly obvious just how fair it is.

(I'm not technically rewatching right now, but between The Greatest Generation: Deep Space 9, [personal profile] sohotrightnow's blog posts and [personal profile] nostalgia doing a rewatch, I may as well be.)

"Character is biologically determined to seek order; is naturally authoritarian as a result" is an interesting premise, but DS9 doesn't really consider the logical next questions, ie, "Is that a good thing?" and "Can he change?" Worse, much of the time they don't seem to realise what it is they're depicting: harassment by law enforcement as comedy; straight-up collaboration.

That's the nadir: the bit in ... season 6? When the station is under Dominion control, and we cut from Quark saying, "Odo would never collaborate" to ... Odo collaborating.

["My Odo is not a collaborator. He may be a liar, a pig, an idiot, a collaborator...but he is NOT a porn star."]

But he's forgiven in the end, even by Kira, and then we all move on as if nothing happened.

Then we come to the worst thing about Odo: his relationship with Kira diminishes her. Admittedly, none of her love interests are much good, but with Odo, she basically becomes an object to be nice guyed into submission.

Runner up: Vic Fontaine, Odo's PUA trainer. Aside from the fact that I find his personality irritating and resent that he takes up so much screentime which could, for example, be dedicated to developing Ezri, it's just kind of obnoxious how DS9 is suddenly doing stories about the personhood of holograms without, for example, doublechecking that Voyager hasn't been covering this exact ground for years.

The rest of the days. It's weird to have this one negative question amidst an otherwise positive and fluffy meme, isn't it? )
lizbee: A sketch of myself (Default)
I'm not answering this one -- I don't really seek out media with characters who are like me. I live in my head already; I consume fiction to get out of it.

(I also actively avoid fiction whose main characters share my health issues. Representation matters for some people; for me, it just makes me cranky and anxious. I wouldn't have read Mary Robinette Kowal's Lady Astronaut books if I'd known the heroine suffered from anxiety; I liked the books okay in the end, but had to skip big chunks.)

The rest of the days. )
lizbee: (Star Trek: Data)
[Yes, I took a day off. I'm sure you were all very relieved.]

Bearing in mind that I've only seen the first two seasons of ENT: "Regeneration", the Borg episode.

I remember when it was first announced, because I wasn't watching Star Trek at the time, but I still poked my head up from writing Snape fic and went, "Oh, come on, the Borg? Don't they care about canon AT ALL?"

But it turns out they ... really, really did. This is the best kind of fanwank, taking old plotholes (how did the Hansens know to go Borg hunting a decade or so before "Q Who"? Why were the Borg destroying bases along the neutral zone in season 1 of TNG?) and weaving them -- forgive the mixed metaphor -- into something coherent.

It's also tense, scary, disturbing, all the things you want from a Borg story. It uses the ensemble well -- although I think Phlox's recovery from near-assimilation was too easy -- and was just a really fun episode to watch.

And yes, it created some new plotholes, eg, how didn't Picard or Data know to connect the Borg to this incident later on, but my headcanon is that the Federation's approach to information management is nearly as bad as the Jedi's (and that's how they think they can get away with "We're just gonna tell people never to talk about the USS Discovery and their crew ever again".) It's Section 31's fault, probably.

Runners up: any episode with Shran. Even the ones I haven't seen yet, probably.

The rest of the days. )
lizbee: (Star Trek: Saavik)
I don't really have strong feelings about this, but I do wish we could see more of the Orions, and in spheres beyond sex work. Disco has done that to an extent, but ... we could have more! More green people! Who aren't almost naked! Who have agendas and politics and ambitions!

(I have to congratulate DS9 for giving us Orion Crime Syndicate stories without actual Orions. Is it a franchise now?)

I think Tendi, the green woman in Lower Decks, is meant to be an Orion, although the green hair is unusual. So we're on track!

More days! )
lizbee: (Star Trek: Picard/Beverly)
Recency bias is a factor here, because the book I'm about to name is the one I've read most recently -- but, in my defence, I was reading it because it was my favourite when I was young, and I was delighted to learn that it holds up: The Devil's Heart by Carmen Carter.

If you listened to the Antimatter Pod episode about formative tie-ins, you'll have already heard me rave about it, so please hold while I try to come up with something fresh to say...

*drinks coffee*

RIGHT! Okay, so I'm writing an essay/blog post (it has footnotes, but also gifs) about the gender gap in Trek tie-ins, and at one point I got to rambling semi-coherently musing about the differences between tie-in fiction and fan fiction.

Have a sneak peek:

Fan fiction and tie-in fiction are not, to my mind, interchangeable -- setting aside issues of quality and editorial gatekeeping, I believe they serve similar and often overlapping, but ultimately different needs.

To me, the best tie-in fiction is basically plotty gen -- or, at least, has no more overt romance than the series it's based on, although that gives you a pretty flexible range depending on the series. And the character growth it has to be consistent with the series as well, and where the series is likely to go in the future (which is, I suspect, why the Discovery novels so far have all been prequels). But, at the same time, there has to be as much affection for and interest in the characters as you'd get from fan fiction, or else it's just ... flat.

Fic writing has a lot more freedom to get into the iddy stuff, to change everything, to ignore or alter details of canon that the author doesn't like, to focus entirely on one character (or one relationship) to the exclusion of all else. That's why it's so wonderful!

But sometimes, I want a straightforward adventure with a lot of plot, and fic can't always provide that. And it's what The Devil's Heart does so well. Carter's love for the characters (except Worf, she doesn't seem too fond of him) is evident, her crush on Patrick Stewart and Picard/Crusher shipping are both extremely obvious, but this is also a romp through the history of the alpha quadrant, with a sideline in fanwank (Iconians! The T'Kon Empire! Surak!) and some really strong, diverse original characters, a significant proportion of which are women.

(It's difficult to choose a favourite, but it's a toss-up between the moody Starfleet officer whose career has hit a dead end in the form of commanding a dodgy old starbase, or the Mysterious Bartender who becomes her best frenemy.)

My only complaint, reading it a few months ago, is that the Kindle edition is poorly formatted, and has a handful of errors which look like the product a scan-to-text that wasn't properly proofread. Maybe it's time to hit eBay and find a paperback copy...

The remaining days. )
lizbee: (Star Trek: Janeway)
Easy: "Counterpoint". In which Janeway plays mind games with a space fascist and wins in the sense that she saves her people, but loses in the sense that she hoped she was wrong about his sudden and inevitable betrayal.

It's not just a great script, and one of Voyager's perfect little standalone episodes, but it spawned a lot of good fic and a whole mailing list, which is where I first encountered some people who are still friends to this day.

(The script was by Michael Taylor, who also wrote DS9's "In the Pale Moonlight", and went on to work on BSG. The man likes his morally ambiguous space dramas, and I respect that.)

The rest of the days. )
lizbee: (Star Trek: Data)
This is almost as hard as choosing a favourite captain, and I declined to answer that one. Lemme just go down the list and see how I feel...

Spock: pulling double duty as both science office and second in command. Versatile. Excellent eye make-up. Isn't the most iconic character of the franchise for no reason. I love him. But is he my favourite? Out of all the first officers?

Riker: thrown in because they needed a Manly Macho Man, and yet I've come to love him. Can be relied on for bad trombone, good poker, always has his people's back. Solid.

Kira: a tiny ball of rage and frustration, therefore I love her. Initially working against Sisko and undermining him, which is not ideal in a first officer, but entertaining and consistent with her worldview.

Chakotay: increasingly redundant to the narrative; weirdly passive-aggressive. I like him a lot in the early seasons, but then it turns to indifference and then dislike. So he's the only person who is NOT a contender.

T'Pol: deserves better, starting with her costumes. 100% mentored young Michael Burnham. I adore her.

Saru: also passive-aggressive, but in a really delightful way? He's a tall, delicious horse-sheep man and he's as salty as his tea.

But, after much consideration, I have to give the job to ...



In both her incarnations -- although it irritates me that DSC!Number One is quite different to the TOS incarnation. I mean, they're both great, I just have trouble reconciling them.

But Number One is iconic, and since "The Cage" was the first episode of TOS I ever saw, she gave me a slightly skewed baseline for how the female characters of that era should be written.

The rest of the days. We're at the halfway point! )

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 5th, 2025 03:43 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios