lizbee | (Reply)

From:

"True, but I have to say that the Dalek episode in Season 5 was worse. Mind you, it was the ONLY dud episode in Season 5."

I don't know, "Victory of the Daleks" was exceptionally silly, but it didn't have the Doctor and companion being hateful to someone for failing to meet the rules he hadn't even specifically set.

"To be fair, they were criticising Rusty for that too. If I recall correctly, George Ivanoff opened that phase with "both Rusty and The Smoff were following the George Lucas school of writing", and he then proceeded to summarize every single Epic Finale in New Who."

Oh yeah, I'd totally forgotten about that!

"No, you were at the "Boxcutters Presents: Writing Doctor Who" one, because that's where I bumped into you. Unless you had somehow sneaked into the back and hadn't actually gone to the panel? Or does that one not count because it wasn't, strictly speaking, a "panel"?"

I wasn't really thinking of it as a panel. Not least because I was standing at the very back, and couldn't take notes, and obviously without notes, it never happened. Even though I enjoyed it more than the actual panels themselves.